When I initially looked at this post I was thinking this was a good $2-3K high, but I missed that it was a 35i.
Given that, the KBB range for it in my zip code would be $28.7K to $32.7K it's really not priced badly. That said, I personally would (and did) go with a 28i for several thousand less. Even with the four banger it has plenty of zip
